Hello Cookiebaker,
I am also from Southwestern PA. I just started taking alli on Saturday, 08/11/07, therefore, I don't know if its working. I am pretty confident that I will see a loss at my first weigh in ( oh, how I hope), because I lost 5 lbs. last week by just changing my diet. I, too, am unable to eat 1800 calories a day, but am keeping my fat grams low (sometimes, too low).
I am having the most trouble with motivating myself to exercise. I want to start walking in the evenings, but can't seem to get moving....
Anyway, I am glad to see that there is someone here from my neck of the woods. Good luck to you, and I will keep up with your progress.